You don't always get what you want.......

I recently had a difficulty with the part-time worker regulations (PTW). There is a tension between the PTW and the fixed terms worker regulations (FTW) created when the PTWR were amended to allow direct comparison between workers on fixed term part time contracts and those on permanent full time contracts.

In my particular case the Tribunal were happy to find that the fixed term contract had been lawfully terminated but would not allow the termination of the fixed term contract to be used to justify less favourable treatment based on the workers part time status. Now I can understand that certain factual situations will mean that justification on the basis of being engaged on a fixed term contract won't work. Nevertheless it came as quite a shock to have the Tribunal find against my client and say that in no circumstances could the fact of someone’s fixed term status be relied on as justification. This is despite there being clear government guidance to the contrary.

Update (29/10/08)

The appeal on this one has been lodged with the Court of Appeal and the client is presently considering its options.

So with a sense of pique and with the client needing to clarify the matter we went off to the Employment Appeal Tribunal. It was Monday, the sun was shining and the Judge was making all the right noises and appeared to understand the importance of the point. I should have realised when the Appeal Tribunal had been out for over 30 minutes that things were not looking good.

Sure enough back come the Appeal Tribunal who then launch into a judgment that asks more questions than it answers. Yes we think the original Tribunal was wrong but no we don't see how this would have changed the decision and we are not setting down any guidance on this matter. Appeal dismissed!

So what do I now advise client's who have employed people on fixed term part-time contracts? It is back to the usual, 'this matter is not free from doubt and is likely to be determined on the facts of each case'. The type of advice a client does not want to hear and certainly not the advice that I thought I would be giving after the appeal!